Audio: Listen to this article.
Tigerfox Immerse 360
An in-house-portable immersive audio system
Once in a while, something happens to you, and you cannot describe your reaction. Do you remember the first time you heard —A Great Horned Owl in the Woods on a winter night, Led Zeppelin, Stairway to Heaven, or A Family of Coyotes Talking to each other on a summer evening? Your brain is at a loss, and your emotions swing.
My first experience with the Immerse 360 was at the 2022 Axpona Audio Show. I was stunned and confused by the demo. Yet I was amazed. Is this the future? How the heck did this thing work? Was there a gimmick? It is 18 months later, in June of 2023, and I finally have a path to navigate for this review.
Here are my first impressions after I first listened inside the Tigerfox Immerse 360:
Background
I started building my 7.1.4 ATMOS audio-only playback system last fall, which I completed early this year. After spending a lot of quality time in and around the listening chair, I have a good idea of what ATMOS can do. I also have the words and experience to describe the Immerse 360. While the ATMOS system was built for different reasons, it has proven to me that immersive audio is here to stay in my listening rooms.
One of the keys to immersive system design is the correction for the room, the speakers, and the first arrival time to the listener's ears! Timing is everything. In my ATMOS system, these corrections are done via Digital Signal Processing software and proper room measurements, with custom correction profiles which are very effective.
If you look at the setup of my ATMOS system, its design is primarily near-field. Everything is contained in a 12ft x 16ft space with less than 8ft ceiling height. Near-field listening helps improve the overall sound by bringing the direct sound closer to the listener.
On the other hand, the Immerse 360 pod is a portable single-listener near-field system designed to provide the proper timing of first-order reflections where the music is presented to the user as an immersive sound field. The roll-up wall is an acoustic soundboard reflecting the speaker's audio to the listener and, on the outside, reflecting away extraneous sound. Pure Physics! This system concentrates the audio inside the pod, reducing power needs and controlling the sound field. Finally, the wall is black, reducing visual distractions.
Some will balk at the presence or the look of the Immerse 360, but with the fast setup and take-down, that is simple to mitigate.
Over the last few years, I have learned that spatial data can be heard in many 2-channel recordings. Our standard 2-channel playback systems launch that information into the room environment, where most of it is destroyed by reflections, crosstalk, and timing errors. Headphone listening demonstrates this as well.
The Path
It has been a rather long road to get where I am today! Some of the steps along the route are worth talking about.
The TigerFox team has used Apple iPhones, the Apple Dongle DAC, or other USB DACs like the AudioQuest Dragonfly series. The DAC is then cabled to the speakers, chiefly Studio Monitor types. I set up the Immerse 360 with an eclectic list of speakers and designs. I have used multiple DAC and Streaming Amplifiers in the system. I have decided that I do not need to go overboard. While $20,000 of hardware in the system's front end was terrific, it was also unnecessary and out of character for a $479 portable room in my use case.
One of the critical portions of the setup process is placing the wall ends against the speaker's side! This can create issues with existing stands where the baseplate interferes with the pod wall. You can see this problem in the setup shot of the LS60 speakers.
We mitigated that manually after that shot. My friend Chris was shocked at how much better it sounded with the wall aligned. Physics Wins Again! Thanks to the folks at Holm Audio for allowing me to listen one late evening!
SPEAKERS
(Choose wisely)
I have set up the following speakers in the Immerse 360 and will briefly outline my observations.
JBL 305B
This is the first speaker I heard at Axpona, and DAMN, it works well.
M-Audio BX-5
These were my first studio Monitors. They are old, and they are not up to the task.
Dali Minuet SE
I set these up with an Arcam SA-30, and they did not do it for me. Sad as they sound great on their own.
Kali IN-5
Something about the concentric tweeter messes with the physics, and they do not sound right at all.
Dali Calisto 2C
These have a dual tweeter system, which also messes with the physics.
Heavenly Soundworks 517
The best sound in the Immerse 360 I have heard.
Audio Engine A2+
For $270 a pair, these win the low-cost award. They sound great, and this is a winning combo with the small sub (another $299).
Sonos Move (pair)
OK, laugh at me all you want. These work exceptionally well in the pod.
KEF LS-60
I was initially astounded at how they sound, but I must evaluate them further. Again they are also out of the cost profile I want to use.
Accessories and People
I have been fussing over just the right chair for the Immerse 360. I borrowed folding chairs, test-fitted old chairs, and so many chairs! Comfort is essential so is lower seat height so that your ears are correctly placed in the vertical plane. I am working with the two Ikea chairs suggested by the TigerFox team. I am a lot closer to “Just Right.” Oh, storing extra chairs is a lot worse than equipment boxes!
Speaker stands have been another piece of the puzzle. The base gets in the way of the bottom of the pod wall; the stand is too flimsy or too heavy to move in place. I have a solution I will talk about towards the end of the review.
Wires are the bane of my existence! Passive speakers have the advantage that they only need speaker cables. Active speakers simplify the full setup but need power, and interconnects run out to the speakers.
Smartphones and Dongle DACs have wires running between them and out to the speakers. Is there no end to cables?
I have a solution; read on.
More Physics
Before I get into some sound comparisons, I want to talk more about physics. A few years ago, I was getting my annual physical, and the nurse measured my height at 5’ 5”. Which is about 2” shorter than when I was younger; gravity sucks! This is a time when being a short person is an advantage. I have some friends who tower over me, and they do not get the best experience. Very tall individuals need to plan how they will get proper head placement in the Immerse 360. Bean bag Chair? Yoga Pose?
My TigerFox system
Setup and Listening
The combination of the TigerFox Immerse 360 and a pair of Sonos Move Speakers gives me a fantastic immersive sound system that I can set up in almost any room of my house. All run on batteries with no wires. My system is controlled with either an iPad or an iPhone. I like using my iPad mini with Apple Pencil as the controller hardware.
Sonos limits the audio bit rate to 24/48 PCM on the S2 systems like the Move speakers, so do not expect to play DSD 1024. The Sonos App has an extensive menu of integrations to select from. In addition, the Move is an Airplay device.
My base setup is Sonos Radio and Apple Music, with BandCamp and SoundCloud for direct artist interactions and Focus@will for sound therapy.
The Sonos Move speakers are the stereo listening system in my Living Room. Since they are battery-powered, they can be taken from their docking rings to any location in the house as long as the Sonos network reaches them.
Speaking of “Time,” I will start with Pink Floyd’s Time from the Dark Side of the Moon. I created a playlist on Apple Music for this review, the first track is Time from the 50’th remix in ATMOS, and the second is the original version from 1973, also on Apple Music.
NOTE: I am out of my comfort zone diving down to individual tracks. Usually, I would be listening to the whole album: “As the Artist Intended?”
The only reason for both tracks is to understand what has changed from the original. I enjoy the new release. The sound placement is precise and easy to track when listening in ATMOS on my 7.1.4 system. Listening in the Pod with 2-channel speakers, the sound placement comes from the exact locations as the ATMOS playback! It is uncanny.
Next, I want to introduce you to Todd Boston. Todd is a musician, producer, and composer. Todd has an “Hope” album that you can find on Apple Music in the original and ATMOS under “Hope Deluxe.” Grab the track “Spiral” from both into a playlist for convenience. Todd used his mastering skills to build the ATMOS version, and the new version is haunting! Sitting in the Immerse 360 enhances the sound of the entire experience with the reduction in outside stimulation. In this case, I prefer listening to this track in the Pod vs. the ATMOS system.
Here is a second introduction. The Artist is BT. The album is from 2006, “This Binary Universe.” You can read his biography on Apple Music. BT has given us many gifts, from his music to software engineering and audio plug-in development! Check out Stutter Edit 2 in iZOTOPE:
I'm BT, and This Is Stutter Edit 2:
This Binary Universe is a stereo album with some fantastic immersive content hidden inside. Try this one on your best headphones to start with. In the Immerse 360, you must listen to the whole hour and 14 minutes of the album!
Rick O’Polka at TigerFox has a collection of tracks he uses for demoing the Immerse 360. I converted that playlist to Apple Music here.
Is this the end?
I always dread the end of an article. First, it feels so final; second, I worry I missed something or went astray. In this case, I feel torn inside. I have two immersive sound systems. One that looks forward in my ATMOS 7.1.4 and one that screams hey do not forget what is already here. Both are single-listener systems that only have one sweet spot per system. I only have one “perfect” chair to use in both systems. I am torn when casually listening in the Living Room: I wonder what this would sound like in one of the immersive systems. I am torn when I want to share the immersive audio experience with others. Nothing is perfect, and I always seek the right balance. I am the only one who sits down to listen on purpose to listen to music—building the ATMOS system in the basement to not interfere with others’ entertainment.
I hope I have been able to convey the value and experience of the Immerse 360 to you. I also hope that you understand the trade-offs. I have assembled a system that is easy to set up and tear down. There are no wires to deal with, and you can use the system in almost any room in your home.
One (two) More Thing(s)
I have been setting up the Pod in the center of my listening room to listen to immersive 2-channel music with the Sonos Move speakers.
I assembled a two-speaker support from a cut-down shelf clamped to a hefty Monolith 28 speaker stand in the middle. This way, the speaker stand does not interfere with Immerse 360 wall. The move speakers sit so that they hold the wall ends in place! I enter and exit the Pod by opening one side.
I have been listening extensively in the Pod over the last couple of weeks. My second system design is a bit more conventional and has wires! I love the AudioEngine A2+ speakers even without their sub. Using the JDS Labs Element III DAC/preamp puts it over the top. I can also switch to headphones to compare. I have not decided about using the IsoAcousitcs stands. The wiring is all out of the way. I mostly use Apple Music on the iPad for playback in this system.
Tigerfox Immerse 360 setup using the Audio Engine A2+ speakers.
Using a single speaker stand with a shelf attached to the top, I have aligned the shelf with the speaker placement markers on the base. The speakers are on Audioengine small wedge stands. I have notched the ends of the shelf to hold the ends of the Pod walls in place next to the speakers.
Equipment List
- Two Sonos Move Speakers $800
- Audio Engine A2+ $269
- JDS Labs Element 3 $450
- iPad mini 5 $499
- Tigerfox Immerse 360 $479
- Two Flexson Stands $300 (in the Living room)
- One Monolith 28in stand $60
Where do I go from here?
Both my ATMOS system and the Immerse 360 could be considered unconventional. One has twelve speakers, and the other has this wall you set up in the room. One has more wires than 99.9% of systems; the other has no cables and relies on batteries. I have two more ideas for immersive audio systems, and the hardware is on the way for one!
Note. Thanks to Rick O’Polka for assistance in understanding the design and goals for the Immerse 360. Also, thanks to Tony Tang for the Axpona videos.
Recommended Comments
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now