Jump to content
  • The Computer Audiophile

    Pearl Jam’s Dark Matter In TrueHD Dolby Atmos

     

     

        

        Audio: Listen to this article.

     

     

     

    This month the Sun, Moon, and Earth aligned, record store day fell on 4/20, and Pearl Jam released a new album. One of the aforementioned items made my eyes well up, delivering an emotion experience about which I’ll be talking for a long time. Eclipses are neat and 4/20 meant more to me back in the day, but the new Pearl Jam record, Dark Matter, is something special.

     

    In 1991 I went from an eighth grader listening to misogynistic Motley Crue to a high school freshman awakened by Pearl Jam’s debut album Ten and the band’s activism. Pearl Jam changed my life, and I can’t imagine it going any other way. I would happily take PJ’s music on a mono AM radio, like the one on which my dad listened to WCCO 830 in the bathroom every morning, rather than any other band’s music on the world’s highest resolution stereo. It’s about the music, the message, and the emotion. Sure, we hear music with our ears, but some music we feel in our hearts.

     

    Like the rare solar eclipse, once in a great while we experience the perfect sonic storm, in the best way imaginable. A sublime storm that mixes our favorite music with incredible sound quality, to be played on an audio system built for just this purpose. On April 19th Pearl Jam released Dark Matter on Blu-ray Disc, among many other formats and variants, containing a high resolution TrueHD Dolby Atmos immersive mix. This is an absolute game changer.

     

    The main ingredient in this perfect storm is of course an album that I love. Every song on Dark Matter is impactful musically and lyrically. Track one, "Scared of Fear," gets my heart going and my mind imagining what it’s going to sound like live. The opening guitar riff is an instant classic, and one that I can see the band kicking their chairs aside, to launch into after opening a show seated, playing some slower tempo tracks.

     

    The title track, "Dark Matter," is as close to a perfect Pearl Jam song as I’ve ever heard. Matt Cameron pounding the drum kit in fine form, Stone Gossard playing sick and filthy riffs, Mike McCready ripping a solo that’ll melt your face, Jeff Ament providing the groove to which Eddie Vedder lays down some potent truth-to-power lyrics. I dare anyone to listen to this song and not feel the energy. It’s going to be a banger live in concert.

     

    Speaking of guitar, Mike McCready’s solos on this album are plentiful and legendary. For example, the track "Upper Hand" has two guitar leads. The first is David Gilmour-esque, his influence on McCready and Pearl Jam in general can’t be overstated. McCready actually wrote out the first lead before recording the song. With roughly a minute left in the song McCready flows into one of his memorable, off the cuff, leads for which he’s come to be known. It’s believable and unbelievable that most of his guitar leads are unwritten, played in one take, and based on the feeling he gets from the music, other guys in the band, and raw emotion. On this entire Dark Matter album, McCready solidifies his status even more, as another Pacific Northwest guitar god.

     

    The biggest surprise for me on Dark Matter is the drumming of Matt Cameron. Of course he was the hard hitting drummer for Soundgarden and has backed Pearl Jam for seemingly ever, but I’ve never heard him play like this. He plays like a madman influenced by a combination of John Bonham and Buddy Rich! The first time I heard this album, it was Cameron’s drumming that amazed me and got me really excited, more than anything. Perhaps he was a touch polite on some of the previous albums, but on Dark Matter he’s a launch pad, enabling this band to reach new heights.

     

    Lyrically, Dark Matter is full of what many of us love about Pearl Jam. Thoughtful lyrics with meaning, perceptive turns of phrase, and above all lyrics with endless emotion. Eddie Vedder puts emotion into his lyrics, that pulls emotion out of us listeners upon playback. No song captures this more than "Something Special." If you don’t feel something listening to this song, or even reading this first verse, chances are you aren’t a parent. As a parent, especially of a daughter, I connect with this song more than any other. (Tidal link)

     

    If you could see what I see now

    You gotta know I'm looking up, oh, so proud

    The one I used to hold is, oh, so special

    Mmm, and every setback now but a chance to grow

    If further proof that you're phenomenal

    You better believe it that you are something special

    Whoa, ooh, whoa

    Afraid to fail, oh, same as afraid to try

    These are the days to accept all the invites

    'Cause you're so cool and, baby, on the level

     

     

     

    Let’s Talk About Sound and Immersion

     

    PJ DM I.jpgThe other ingredient in this perfect storm of greatness, is the team behind the scenes. Like all albums, there are countless people involved in getting an album out the door. A great Dolby Atmos mix requires engineers who understand the band and its music, have adequate time to create something special, and understand the technology involved in taking this music to another level. On Dark Matter, and all Pearl Jam immersive releases, these engineers are Josh Evans and Nick Rives. These guys are the best in the business at using the right, and right amount of, technology to serve the music and deliver an immersive experience unavailable from any other format.

     

    What Josh Evans and Nick Rives have created with the Dolby Atmos version of Dark Matter is nothing short of a masterpiece. This mix will be used as the benchmark by which other releases are measureed /  judged, although judging art is a fool’s errand. Speaking of judging, these guys absolutely deserve a Grammy nomination for Best Immersive Audio Album. I’ll be watching the announcements come November. They went for it, took chances, and created an unsurpassed experience that brought me closer to Pearl Jam’s music than ever before.

     

    There’s only one “first time” and the first time I listened to Dark Matter in Dolby Atmos, my eyes welled up with tears. It was this perfect storm hitting home. As previously mentioned, the music was fantastic, and this mix was every bit its equal. I still have goosebumps while I type this, thinking about the experience.

     

    Right from the opening of the opening track, it was evident that Dark Matter, the album, was special. The opening music emanates from behind the listener, building toward the front, then BAM! "Scared of Fear" kicks into gear with a front and center guitar riff, followed by guitars that fill in from the sides. Bass and drums are in lock-step together in the front, to maintain a solidly cohesive sonic image. On the chorus, backing vocals can be heard from the sides, supporting the main vocal, in a way that lifts up the entire performance. It’s as if this support from the side is elevating, and it serves the track amazingly well.

     

    The Atmos mix on the title track, "Dark Matter," is so extraordinary, that once it’s heard, there’s no going back to the stereo version. Seriously, hearing "Dark Matter" in Atmos, with Matt Cameron banging away up front, supporting guitars loading the soundstage in front and on the side, other sounds ducking in and out appropriately from other speakers, is like no other Pearl Jam experience I’ve had while listening at home since 1991.

     

    But wait there’s more, at about 2:45 into "Dark Matter," when Mike McCready rips into his lead guitar solo, Josh Evans and Nick Rives brilliantly elevate the soundstage through heavy use of the front two height channels, meanwhile the rest of the band continues to sling riffs around like Barry Sanders scores touchdowns (incredibly talented, but acting like he’s been there before). The "Dark Matter" title track is now THE track I will play for people who visit my listening room, and want to experience music in a way they never thought possible. It’s the perfect Pearl Jam song, and the perfect immersive Atmos mix.

     

    Flipping the script a bit, Josh Evans and Nick Rives preset the track "Something Special" and all its emotional pull, in a way that’s incredibly organic. From my listening chair, I feel like I’m sitting in Shangri-La studio in Malibu, CA with Mike, Stone, Jeff, Matt and Eddie around circle in the same room with me. Eddie singing up front with Matt and Jeff keeping the rhythm, with Stone and Jeff sitting to my right and left sides around the circle, playing guitars and adding some backing vocals when appropriate. This sonic immersion elevates an already emotional song into an ethereal experience, where theater of the mind transports the listener into another time and place. No visual queues necessary, or even allowed. The Dolby Atmos mix of Something Special is something special.

     

     

    Dark Matter and Immersive Wrap Up

     

    This is a perfect storm that’s as rare as a solar eclipse. Anyone with a pulse can see why I was in tears. It’s my favorite band. It’s my favorite music. It’s my favorite way to listen to music. It’s high resolution TrueHD Dolby Atmos. It’s absolute perfection.

     

    The immersive version of Dark Matter is for everyone, even if they have’t realized it yet. A sonic experience this distinctive can’t hide behind the already acclaimed stereo version. It also shouldn’t leap ahead of it because this isn’t competition. The Atmos version of Dark Matter is yet another way to experience music, get closer to the emotional magnetism and electric energy put out by Pearl Jam.

     

    In addition, this Atmos mix solidifies the album’s place as a must-have for future Pearl Jam fans and immersive music lovers. When my twelve year old daughter and her friends come up to my listening room to hear Pearl Jam, Taylor Swift, Olivia Rodrigo, or Billie Eilish, which version do you think they ask for, stereo or Atmos? It’s all about Atmos for them, all day long, and they even request it by name. As Neil Young said, he’s “making all [his] old albums in Dolby Atmos / Apple Spatial so the next generation can hear them.” When the next generations listen to Dark Matter in Atmos, they’ll be affected like the first time some people heard Dark Side of the Moon, or like the first time I listened to Ten in 1991. It’s an unforgettable experience.

     

    Dark Matter, produced by Andrew Watt, is an instant classic in and of itself. Whether on AM radio, satellite radio, a vinyl record, streamed high resolution, or TrueHD Dolby Atmos, the music remains powerful, emotional, and energizing. The Atmos mix by Josh Evans and Nick Rives released on Blu-ray Disc in TrueHD Dolby Atmos is unsurpassed and brings this music to another level entirely. This perfect storm brought tears to my eyes, the very first time I listened to the album. I can’t say that’s ever happened before, as it usually takes a strong historical and emotional connection for me to get emotional when listening.

     

    It’s time to crank this album again, memorize more lyrics, and get ready to see the band live this summer. Hearing Dark Matter live is going to be legendary.

     

     

     

     

    ccff467ac8ba220f6d214359b0b72530.png copy.jpgPearl Jam

    Dark Matter

    Deluxe CD & Blu-ray

    Buy the album HERE

     

     

     

    About the author - https://audiophile.style/about
    Author's Complete Audio System Details with Measurements - https://audiophile.style/system

     

     

     

    Note: If the video above doesn't work well, please click here to view it on the Matterport site.

     




    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    @The Computer Audiophile I likely missed something but in the room tour, I didn't see the Mytek stack. Have the amps been located out of sight?

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    6 hours ago, loop7 said:

    @The Computer Audiophile I likely missed something but in the room tour, I didn't see the Mytek stack. Have the amps been located out of sight?

    Yes. Everything except the Constellation mono amps is behind the walls on the left or right of the room. 

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Hi Guys, just a follow up to the article. I should've posted this in the main text because for audiophiles it's really important. 

     

    Check out the dynamic range in the TrueHD Atmos version compared to the stereo version. It's over double!

     

     

    TrueHD Atmos:

    Dark Matter Dynamic Range TrueHD Atmos.png

     

     

     

    Stereo:

    Dark Matter Stereo Dynamic Range 01.png

    Dark Matter Stereo Dynamic Range 02.png

     

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    1 hour ago, The Computer Audiophile said:

    Hi Guys, just a follow up to the article. I should've posted this in the main text because for audiophiles it's really important. 

     

    Check out the dynamic range in the TrueHD Atmos version compared to the stereo version. It's over double!

     

     

    Is the stereo version from the same Blu-ray disc, or is this a download?

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    7 minutes ago, Apollo said:

     

    Is the stereo version from the same Blu-ray disc, or is this a download?

    The stereo version on the Blu-ray is identical to the high resolution download, and nearly identical to the CD, except the CD is 44.1.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Odd, then, that Roon reports a 7 for dynamic range of the Atmos version. JCR 

    IMG_1421.jpeg

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    1 minute ago, jrobbins50 said:

    Odd, then, that Roon reports a 7 for dynamic range of the Atmos version. JCR 

    IMG_1421.jpeg

    R128?

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Thank you for the beautiful write-up, Chris.  I concur on the album itself; I'm still completely floored that they were able to achieve such incredible results well into their fourth decade.  It's truly a staggering album.  One that has routinely brought tears to my eyes since release.

     

    As for the Atmos portion, I must admit that it's genuinely baffling to me to read such a glowing review. 

     

    Josh Evans himself will readily admit that he was just getting acquainted with the technology when Gigaton came out.  Hell, when he was asked to mix it in Atmos for release, he barely knew what the technology was.

     

    Fast-forward a few years...After having "sat under the learning tree" with Nick Rives, undoubtedly one of the best in the business, his work re-mixing both Yield and No Code in Atmos during the summer of 2019 displayed a staggering improvement and and a fully-assured grasp on the format. 

     

    All of the above is to underscore why I was so heartbroken to hear what I was sure was going to be a demo worthy disc in Dolby Atmos sound like such a disappointment.

     

    Granted, I'm not blessed with the most mind-blowing 5.1.2 system, but, I'd like to think that it's a bit better than your average big-box store.

     

    I find the vocals in almost every song to sound distant to the point of inaudibility.  The drums and background vocals sound immense, but, everything is sonically smashed beyond recognition and there's a very artificial sounding echo at many points.

     

    I don't want to prattle on and put everyone to sleep...I'll just bring it back around by saying that, unfortunately, to my ears, and on my system, at least, Gigaton sounds like a shining example compared to this, and, I'm not yet sure why.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    54 minutes ago, oneway23 said:

    Thank you for the beautiful write-up, Chris.  I concur on the album itself; I'm still completely floored that they were able to achieve such incredible results well into their fourth decade.  It's truly a staggering album.  One that has routinely brought tears to my eyes since release.

     

    As for the Atmos portion, I must admit that it's genuinely baffling to me to read such a glowing review. 

     

    Josh Evans himself will readily admit that he was just getting acquainted with the technology when Gigaton came out.  Hell, when he was asked to mix it in Atmos for release, he barely knew what the technology was.

     

    Fast-forward a few years...After having "sat under the learning tree" with Nick Rives, undoubtedly one of the best in the business, his work re-mixing both Yield and No Code in Atmos during the summer of 2019 displayed a staggering improvement and and a fully-assured grasp on the format. 

     

    All of the above is to underscore why I was so heartbroken to hear what I was sure was going to be a demo worthy disc in Dolby Atmos sound like such a disappointment.

     

    Granted, I'm not blessed with the most mind-blowing 5.1.2 system, but, I'd like to think that it's a bit better than your average big-box store.

     

    I find the vocals in almost every song to sound distant to the point of inaudibility.  The drums and background vocals sound immense, but, everything is sonically smashed beyond recognition and there's a very artificial sounding echo at many points.

     

    I don't want to prattle on and put everyone to sleep...I'll just bring it back around by saying that, unfortunately, to my ears, and on my system, at least, Gigaton sounds like a shining example compared to this, and, I'm not yet sure why.

     

    Hi @oneway23, thanks for the kind words. I so happy we both share a love of this album. Without great music, none of the other stuff even matters. I was just listening to this album in the car after morning drop off (school), and I'm still hearing more nuances and enjoying it more with every listen. The musicianship is so fantastic and the emotion this music pulls out of the listener is next level!

     

    With respect to the Atmos mix - I've seen a couple people say the same thing as you about the vocals, and I'm trying to wrap my head around it. On my system it seriously sounds flawless. Eddie's vocals aren't nearly as recessed as the original Vs. album, which had many record company execs up in arms. On Dark Matter in Atmos they are perfect. 

     

    When I heard this at the theater, the horn speakers made it sound like Eddie was singing through a traffic cone, and he was very audible. 

     

    If we say that 100% would be vocals that are obnoxiously right in your face, and 0% would be vocals that are so distant as to be almost impossible to hear, I'd say the vocals on this album are about 50% to 45%. 

     

    In terms of dynamics, the Atmos version has over double the dynamic range of the stereo version and it doesn't sound too compressed to me at all. 

     

    This is art after all, and it isn't for everyone. I just wish you liked the Atmos version as much as I do, becuase it's a transcendent experience. 

     

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts :~)

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Took my youngest to see them at Hyde Park in '22, supported by the Pixies. Both bands were pretty good.

     

    I bought their first 2 albums when they came out but lost interest in their subsequent work.

    I'll give this new album a go, although my kid has told me this morning that he wasn't that impressed on his first listen.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now




×
×
  • Create New...