Jump to content
  • The Computer Audiophile

    Great Music In A Difficult Environment

     

     

        

        Audio: Listen to this article.

     

     

     

    Release week is finally here for Pearl Jam’s new album Dark Matter!

     

    It should come as no surprise to members of the Audiophile Style community that I’ve been a diehard Pearl Jam fan since August of 1991 when I purchase the band’s debut album Ten. In fact, I’m sure many people are asking themselves if they really need to hear me talk about PJ more :~)

     

    PJ Theater Official.jpgAnyway, the new album, produced by Andrew Watt, officially comes out Friday, April 19th. Last night, April 16th, the band offered a one night only, global theatrical experience, at theaters around the world. The Dark Matter album was played in its entirety, twice. The first run-through was in the dark, the way I like it, without any visual imagery. The second spin of the album included visualizations created for the experience and lyrics on the screen.

     

    What got me most interested in the event, other than the music of course, was the fact that it was presented in Dolby Atmos. This was my first experience listening to an album mixed for Dolby Atmos in a theater. I’ve spent the last couple years listening to Atmos on my expertly calibrated twelve channel Wilson Audio system, but never in a theater.

     

    If I had to use a single word to sum up the experience, compared to what I’m used to at home, it would be WOW. Wow, the music was fantastic. Wow, the immersive mix was really well done by Josh Evans and Nick Rives. Wow, it was played in an incredibly difficult environment. Wow, the sound quality was less than stellar.

     

    Going into the event, I was looking forward to sharing the experience with my wife and likeminded Pearl Jam fans. A chance to hear the album early, and immersively. That’s what this was all about. It wasn’t an audio system demonstration. And, we all got exactly what we wanted. Great music, some cheers by diehard fans, and a memorable experience.

     

    As an audiophile, writing on Audiophile Style, it behooves me to discuss the audio quality. The most important part of the evening for me was to get into the music and the Atmos mix. I could tell both were great and crafted with the usual Pearl Jam care and expertise.

     

    The quality of the sound in the theater was probably what I expected in the back of my mind, but I wasn’t ready to accept until I heard it in person. Delivering Spatial Audio to a crowd of people sitting a hundred feet apart horizontally a large differential vertically, with a system capable of PA decibel levels, is a challenge to say the least.

     

    The theater sounded very reflective, as if care hadn’t been taken to reduce reflections enough for music. Perhaps this works for movies, but for a band with three guitarists, a bassist, a drummer who’s really killing it, and a host of other featured players, the sound in this theater really over-drove the room. It’s don’t think the volume level did this theater any favors, as the room was overdriven much of the time. The speakers could certainly handle the volume, but the room couldn’t, as the reflections sounded massive.

     

    On the other hand, without knowing the audio system at all and where the speakers were placed, what I heard as reflections could’ve been a result of the playback system trying to reproduce an album mixed for a much different environment.

     

    I’m far from an expert in the area of theater sound at the commercial level, but I’m OK with evaluating it for my own tastes and comparing it to my own experience at home. This one was just strange, and it had nothing to do with the music or the mix.

     

    dm-brd.jpgI hope that nobody who was at the theater was attempting to judge Dolby Atmos of music last night. It wasn’t a reference level experience, that’s for sure. In fact, a local radio personality sat next to us for the event, and I felt like inviting him over to my listening room to experience this album in all its immersive glory. Perhaps I should reach out to him this afternoon.

     

    The take away for me was that I can’t wait until the high resolution TrueHD Dolby Atmos arrives at my doorstep. I received a shipping notification, and my system is ready to rock. The music is fantastic and the mix serves the music very well. Josh Evans and Nick Rives have a proven track record with Pearl Jam mixes, that shows they understand the music, the meaning, and the tools to immerse listeners and deliver an unparalleled Pearl Jam experience.

     

    The album can’t arrive soon enough!

     

     

     

    About the author - https://audiophile.style/about
    Author's Complete Audio System Details with Measurements - https://audiophile.style/system

     

     

     

     




    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    I asked a vendor at AXPONA to turn down the music in his room to help me understand what the speakers were doing in the room.  He would not.  Did not understand!    When I had the Kii Three speakers in my Living Room they could overpower it with ease.  The Dutch and Dutch 8C would do the same thing.  

     

    I can see what the video / movie centric playback system and operation would have a much greater problem.

     

     

     

     

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    This is very interesting to read, thank you for sharing. From my own setups which are separate for movie and music using Audyssey for the movie sound, I have noticed a definite difference in experience between the two. The Audyssey measurements take several location inputs which I limit to about 6. I have noticed that the system manages to even out the sound for the different locations. To me this has always felt like a little bit of a compromise compared to my music setup which is arranged for a single listening position. I imagine the theater has a similar setup approach with maybe something more advanced/different than Audyssey but multiple location based. If your home immersive setup is focused around a particular listening position, wouldn't that contribute to the difference as well?

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    39 minutes ago, bobfa said:

    I asked a vendor at AXPONA to turn down the music in his room to help me understand what the speakers were doing in the room.  He would not.  Did not understand!    When I had the Kii Three speakers in my Living Room they could overpower it with ease.  The Dutch and Dutch 8C would do the same thing.  

     

    I can see what the video / movie centric playback system and operation would have a much greater problem.

     

     

     

     

     

    I remember going to an old movie theatre in Iowa and they had Altec VoTT's behind the screen for R-C-L and smaller VoTTs for surround. It was interesting to hear that. They did augment with subs also. 

     

    I could see the issue, at the same time, taking in the environment and understanding that, helps with enjoyment.

     

    Sometimes we need to turn off the 'Audiophile perfection' idea. Sometimes it is just nice to enjoy, w/o picking everything apart. (not saying you do - I do it, so speaking for myself).

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    2 hours ago, SQFIRST said:

    This is very interesting to read, thank you for sharing. From my own setups which are separate for movie and music using Audyssey for the movie sound, I have noticed a definite difference in experience between the two. The Audyssey measurements take several location inputs which I limit to about 6. I have noticed that the system manages to even out the sound for the different locations. To me this has always felt like a little bit of a compromise compared to my music setup which is arranged for a single listening position. I imagine the theater has a similar setup approach with maybe something more advanced/different than Audyssey but multiple location based. If your home immersive setup is focused around a particular listening position, wouldn't that contribute to the difference as well?

     

    Absolutely. A theater is a tough environment, especially when compared to a dedicated listening room. 

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Commercial theaters are set up for movies. Completely different perspectives vs. a dedicated listening space. My HT is set up for both movies and Atmos music. So, it can be done, but for just two or three folks. I have yet to hear a commercial theater or large theater space with many, many speakers reproduce Atmos music well. So Chris, I am not surprised with your experience, the disc will no doubt be a much better experience for you.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    1 hour ago, JoeWhip said:

    Commercial theaters are set up for movies. Completely different perspectives vs. a dedicated listening space. My HT is set up for both movies and Atmos music. So, it can be done, but for just two or three folks. I have yet to hear a commercial theater or large theater space with many, many speakers reproduce Atmos music well. So Chris, I am not surprised with your experience, the disc will no doubt be a much better experience for you.

    Some of the larger images use atmos, if I am not mistaken.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    If you mean IMAX, they do not use Atmos.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Where did you sit in the theater and can you share the speaker layout? 

     

    Also, are you coming to Wrigley for the shows? 

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    '84 was an amazing year.  That crazy game Ryne Sandberg had on national tv (on a Saturday afternoon)...  And Rick Sutcliffe being pretty close to perfect.

     

    You know the story about the Leon Durham error late in their final playoff game that opened the door to the Padres coming back to tie and then win, right?  His glove got soaked with Gatorade in the dugout right before the Cubs took the field that inning, and he still chose to use it.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Hi Guys, here's my take on the album in my own room on my own system, as opposed to the theater:

     

     

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now




×
×
  • Create New...