Jump to content


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Country

    United States

Everything posted by JoshM

  1. Thank you. Back in the day, I thought I'd be writing one once every few weeks. But the amount of work I put into each has gone up since then. I look at it as a question of value added. There are lots of articles about The Nightfly out there. I want to write something that will be close to the definitive account of every album I tackle. For me to write them once every few weeks, I'd need to turn it into my real job, which would probably involve Chris helping me spin TBVO off into a freestanding site like SuperDeluxeEdition. That's enticing, but I'm not sure if I'd want to do that fo
  2. His comments in that thread were hilarious. He kept citing Bob Stuart's CV, as if that's a rebuttal to objective analyses of what MQA does and doesn't do. Then he brought up random things like the Apple store's business model. Huh? What does that have to do with MQA? It was also rich to see someone who worked at Microsoft during the '90s and '00s (and whose emails were part of the DOJ's antitrust case against MS!) slamming Apple for monopolistic practices!
  3. The above is impossible! I've heard that, while @The Computer Audiophile is a ruthless censor, Amir cultivates a forum focused on a no-holds-barred exchange of ideas in the search of objective truth. 😉 More seriously, isn't this the second MQA thread that's been locked at ASR because Amir made a fool of himself and got repeatedly dunked on by his followers?
  4. I've never tried folding down the 5.1 mix to stereo. Does HQP do that on-the-fly when playing the 5.1 files, or do you do a conversion beforehand?
  5. Since this site has taken the brave stance of shining a spotlight on MQA, it's worth my mentioning that this article is very wrong about MQA and The Nightfly. The MQA version he listens to is just an MQA-encoded version of the 24/48 release, and both the Redbook streaming version and the 24/88.2 version (which I presume is just a rip of the SACD's hi-res layer) he compares it to are different masterings. So any differences are not attributable to MQA, and in my listening the plain old PCM version of the 24/48 master sounded better than the MQA version even when fully unfolded with my Matrix XS
  6. It's odd that Fremer would blame CDs for the drum sound, since Wendel is really what shaped it. Listening to Wendel tracks on Gaucho, it's the same sound (arguably more digital, since I believe Nichols updated Wendel between Gaucho and The Nightfly). In contrast to Fremer, I agree with the contemporary CD marketers and hifi magazine writers who pointed to The Nightfly as an endorsement of the potential of CDs. Lots of early CDs were sourced from improper tapes, as Nichols himself wrote about in an 1983 article. So even The Nightfly's erroneous first CD issue tended to sound better
  7. I just cleaned up a few missing italicizations of album titles. Please let me know if anyone notices any other errors.
  8. When EQ Magazine asked its readers to select “the best sounding recordings of all time,” Donald Fagen’s 1982 album, The Nightfly, ranked fifth — behind Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, Dark Side of the Moon, Pet Sounds, and Abbey Road, but ahead of Led Zeppelin IV, Electric Ladyland, and Thriller. While at first blush it might seem quixotic to rank the former Steely Dan frontman’s solo debut — which, despite its critical plaudits and whopping seven Grammy nominations, took almost 20 years to go platinum — alongside some of the best-selling albums ever released, EQ’s readers
  9. That’s fascinating. Do you have a link to his comments?
  10. I’m a proud pinko who supports a generous welfare state for individuals, but it’s pretty clear PPP provided opportunities for businesses to game the system and wasn’t very effective at saving jobs. The goal was to prevent employers from laying people off, even temporarily, which would’ve spiked the unemployment rate. However, it arguably would’ve been better to just let the unemployment rate go up. If that was to be avoided at all costs, there were “paycheck guarantee”-type options that would’ve sent money from the government directly to employees while requiring businesses to nominally keep t
  11. Well, it exists enough to have received $180k in PPP. https://projects.propublica.org/coronavirus/bailouts/loans/hometechusa-llc-6118618500
  12. To provide a little context for this, Zune and MS’s competitor to the iTunes Store used a DRM version of WMA designed by Amir. This was also part of Amir’s vision for MS’s video codecs, which caused him to be taken to task by Cory Doctorow, among others.
  13. Great review, Chris, and high praise for the Terminator. How does it compare to the Berkeley Alpha and the Yggy?
  14. I don’t think we need to read to deeply into why Amir has a soft spot for DRM schemes. From the DOJ’s antitrust case against Microsoft:
  15. Did JA ever get the files back? Was that comparison ever written up? I’m still just struggling to understand how anyone believed processing existing PCM into MQA was going to create something better than the input file.
  16. This has always been the infuriating part of his defense of MQA. What’s the point of seeking ever-greater SINAD scores or sharp attenuation filters on a DAC if you’re going to feed it MQA? Amir has said he decided to start ASR because he was so upset with the “poor” measurements of the original Schiit Modi. But based on what Golden’s tests show, if fed lossless PCM the original Modi surely would sound better than a “state of the art” measuring DAC fed MQA!
  17. Not sure whether this is better placed in this thread, the thread on @GoldenOne’s video, or the ASR thread, but: 1) Over at ASR, John Atkinson is claiming that Golden’s test is invalid since everyone knows a lossy encoder (we’re now apparently conceding that MQA is lossy) can’t handle the signals Golden encoded. This is the same claim Amir made, and if you look at John’s “likes” at ASR, he’s “liking” every post criticizing Golden’s test and defending MQA. 2) Amir has just given a response that completely negates the point of every measurement he’s ever done:
  18. @GoldenOne is doing the lord’s work here. I see he’s taken his evidence over to ASR, too, where Amir has previously defended MQA. I’ll summarize the tenor of the conversation with a meme:
  19. Congrats on this brilliant maneuver. I see you’ve already shared on Head-Fi, and your posts are making the rounds on other sites, too. I can’t wait to watch your video.
  20. If clamping force is the main issue, then I'd definitely look at ZMF cans. They all have spring steel headbands that can be adjusted by hand to accommodate different head sizes and shapes, and Zach, the founder of ZMF, has detailed YouTube videos on how to bend their headbands.
  21. I have the same Mac as you, but whenever I’ve run into this issue, it’s been the DAC that I’ve needed to move to break the loop. Does a “cheater” plug on the DAC’s cord end the loop? If so, an Ebtech Hum-X should safely solve the problem in place of the cheater. Also, moving one or both of the components to a pure sine wave UPS might solve the issue.
  22. As a teen and into my 20s, I associated the Dead with old hippies and endless noodling. However, once I listened to American Beauty, I started to “get” the Dead. That initial inroads quickly expanded. Now I’ve watched Long Strange Trip dozens of times, read six or seven books on them, own nearly their entire catalog (live stuff included). Not everything they did was quality, and drugs and other things certainly held them back at times. But at their best the Dead produced some of the most life-affirming, joy-inducing music that America has to offer.
  • Create New...