Jump to content
  • JoshM
    JoshM

    Announcing Josh Mound's Club TBVO

     

     

    “IMO, the absolute connoisseur of audiophile reproduction is not just the guy who picks out the ‘best,’ often very expensive, DAC, amplifier, speakers, audiophile cables, and all the right tweaks; but the one who also knows which is the best release of their favorite music!” 
                                            -- @Archimago

     

     

    Three years ago, Chris ( @The Computer Audiophile) put out a request for new writers for what was then Computer Audiophile. On a whim, I sent him an email expressing interest. 

     

    A decade earlier, I’d gone to college for journalism with an eye towards being a music journalist. As an undergrad, I’d written for various indie music magazines, and I loved it. I ultimately moved into writing about politics and policy, before going on to get a PhD in that area. Comparatively, writing about music seemed, well, frivolous. But I never stopped being a music nerd, and lots of time in front of the computer writing a dissertation gave me an excuse to begin investing in audio.

     

    Little did I know when I emailed Chris back in 2018 that I’d still be writing for Audiophile Style in 2022 and that doing so would bring me new friends, new opportunities, an immense amount of joy. In Let Your Life Speak, Parker J. Palmer wrote, “vocation begins not in what the world needs (which is everything), but in the nature of the human self, in what brings the self joy.” In short, while I’m proud to write and teach about more weighty topics, I can’t deny that writing about music and audio is more fun. These days, we could all use a little more of that.

     

    Music brings beauty into an often-ugly world, and (at its best) being an audiophile is about making sure that beauty doesn’t get obscured. 

     

    As @Archimago put it so well recently, the audiophile pursuit begins with finding the best sounding release of their favorite albums. That’s why the first thing I wrote for Computer Audiophile was the first installment of my “The Best Version Of…” column and why now, over a dozen installments later, I have no plans to stop. I love to help people get closer to great albums by learning about how they were recorded and which release sounds best.

     

    As loyal Audiophile Style readers know, my columns have become longer and more ambitious as time has passed. What started as a short background on the album based on readily available sources plus a brief analysis of its digital releases has morphed into nearly 33 1/3-length explorations of each album’s recording (often based on original interviews), plus extensive table- and graph-heavy vetting of each digital version. 

     

    This growth is a reflection of my passion for TBVO. I love bringing people closer to great music, both by learning more about how it was made and by listening to it in its best form. It also why I’ve been thinking about how to expand TBVO in ways that don’t involve longer word counts. 

     

    There are great albums that, for one reason or another, aren’t great candidates for a full-length TBVO. There might be little published information about their recording and few living people to interview. Or there might not be many digital versions. However, I’d still like to write short appreciations of these albums and analyses of the existing digital releases. I also always have a handful (or more) TBVOs in various states of completion. In this preliminary research, I often discover information that I’d like to share right away, whether they make it into the finished TBVO or not.


    Writing TBVO also has reignited the joy of collecting. Just figuring out how many unique digital masterings exist of an album can be an adventure — one involving lots of detective work and Discogs CD purchases. While I need to rip those CDs to analyze them in Audacity, Har-Bal, and MusicScope, it’s made me think a lot about the fun of collecting physical media in a streaming world. I don’t know if, as Rob Sheffield wrote last year, “the CD revival is finally here” for the general public. But it sure is for me. While streaming promises to place every release at your fingertips, that’s often not the case. The best version of an album may very well be floating out there in the cloud, available at the click of a button, but it may just as likely be trapped in what David Fricke called “this dopey little disc.” In a world of audiophile labels, deluxe reissues, Japanese-only releases, and the like, there’s still an excitement to tracking down those dopey little discs, and I’d like to write about that, too. 

     

    There are, of course, places on the interwebs where such things are talked about. There’s plenty of discussion of various masterings over at Steve Hoffman Forums, for example. But it’s not always clear what’s fact and what’s fiction. Likewise, SuperDeluxeEdition provides excellent coverage of new releases. But releases from years (or decades) ago receive scant attention. 

     

    That’s why I’ve decided to start Club TBVO. A sort-of Consumer Reports for the digital audiophile, Club TBVO will look at out-of-print CDs as often as the latest digital releases, revel in the fun of collecting, and try to separate myth from fact when it comes to tracking down the best digital versions of beloved music. 

     

    After much thought, I decided that a Patreon- or Substack-style subscription model is the best format for Club TBVO. I wouldn’t feel right asking Chris to pay me the same for short posts as he does for full-length TBVOs or gear reviews. Moreover, while Chris pays better than any political newspaper or magazine I’ve written for, including many prestigious rags, the cost of buying all of the digital versions of a given album have sometimes put me in the red for a given TBVO. While this is a side gig for me — and mainly about fun, not money — I do hope (and think) my writing provides some value to readers and would appreciate your support if you agree.

     

    That said, unlike a paywalled newsletter, I’m starting Club TBVO with a voluntary contribution model. Click the button below to contribute:

     

     

    Donate

     

     

    Since the Club is just getting started, I don’t want to lock you (or me) into any particular donation amount or content promise. But, regardless of how much you do (or don’t) contribute, I hope to create something worthwhile for donors and readers. In addition to the “mini TBVOs” and posts about collecting mentioned above, I also plan to offer donors the ability to send me audio files so I can tell them which version of a release they have and to post level-matched samples of albums to let readers compare versions for themselves. 

     

    Beyond contributing to Club TBVO, you can support TBVO with a TBVO shirt*. The design is based on two pieces of early-CD era promotional ephemera. (The first donor to identify both items in the comments below will get a free shirt.)

     

    While I don’t expect TBVO to ever become my main gig, my hope is that Club TBVO will make it easier to sustain and explain TBVO while giving readers more of what (I hope) is valuable information for the discerning digital audiophile. 

     

     

    * If a Club TBVO shirt isn’t your style, designing music and pop culture shirts has become a pandemic hobby for me. Other designs can be found at my wife’s and my site.

     

     

     

     

    Club TBVO Announcement HERO.jpgEditor's Note: Josh and I have brainstormed for several months on how to best to do this. We've had a test Club up for a while and kicked around few different options. As we enter new territory, we are always open to constructive criticism and input from those who love his articles a much as I do. Please give the new Club TBVO look. Josh has dedicated sections for just about anything he wants, including a sub-forum, downloads, and specific activity stream.

    Here's a link to Club TBVO.

     

     




    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    Maybe change the name to TBDVO to reflect no analog versions are included.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Please suggest a contribution amount, or perhaps a couple of monthly contribution levels. I have greatly enjoyed your TBDVO columns and would like to support your writing through the club, but I have no idea of what is reasonable. Thank you!

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    3 hours ago, stereomatters said:

    Please suggest a contribution amount, or perhaps a couple of monthly contribution levels. I have greatly enjoyed your TBDVO columns and would like to support your writing through the club, but I have no idea of what is reasonable. Thank you!

    What’s reasonable is up to each person. There’s no right or wrong or correct amount. Consider what his work is worth to you and support his efforts with that amount. 

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    9 hours ago, stereomatters said:

    Please suggest a contribution amount, or perhaps a couple of monthly contribution levels. I have greatly enjoyed your TBDVO columns and would like to support your writing through the club, but I have no idea of what is reasonable. Thank you!

     

    I totally second what Chris said. He and I talked about starting it paywalled, but 1) I didn’t want to potentially be writing things only a handful of people would see, and 2) it’s really, really hard to come up with a fair “ask.”
     

    On the one hand, it depends on how much a reader does (or doesn’t) like my work. (I don’t expect everyone to like it equally or at all!) On the other, people’s disposable income varies. My academic work was about tax politics and policy, and declining marginal utility is real. What’s a lot of money to Paul McCartney is going to be very different from what’s a lot of money to a Liverpool music teacher!

     

    If someone who has the means to do so wants to give a lot, great. But I absolutely don’t want anyone living paycheck to paycheck to give to TBVO, period. My wife and I are both public school teachers, though I still teach college classes here and there. So it’s not like we’re rich. But we also don’t have kids or student loans. So my Discogs orders aren’t bankrupting me, either!
     

    As I wrote in the intro, Club TBVO is really about allowing me to write more short content and perhaps making TBVOs consistently net out positive, since it’s not uncommon for me to spend more on versions than I make on the article. But it’s not anyone’s responsibility to make that happen. Writing them is a joy for me, and I appreciate any amount that anyone is able to contribute, either one time or recurring. 

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I will also start with a small donation and plan to raise it as this grows over time.

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    3 hours ago, cgiammona said:

    I will also start with a small donation and plan to raise it as this grows over time.


    Thank you!

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    22 hours ago, Archimago said:

    Hey there @JoshM, I heartily agree with your quote. :-)

     

    Hard work (but hopefully enjoyable!), and essential information which unfortunately we don't have enough of.

     

    A little something just sent over for the awesome job man! 👍


    Thanks so much, Arch!

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Thank you to all who've donated so far. I really appreciate it!

     

    I also wanted to alert everyone to a new post up on Club TBVO about the MoFi "One-Step" controversy and why my TBVO columns are digital-only:

     

     

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    18 minutes ago, JoshM said:

    Thank you to all who've donated so far. I really appreciate it!

     

    I also wanted to alert everyone to a new post up on Club TBVO about the MoFi "One-Step" controversy and why my TBVO columns are digital-only:

     

     

    It’s a fantastic post. 

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Where have you been all these years of me buying crappy issues of many albums that I regret?  Thank you so much for doing this - I think it’s fantastic. 
    I’ve just donated and look forward to more reviews. 

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    👋 Hi, long-time reader, first time poster. Just wanted to say that I've greatly enjoyed the entire series of TBVO and I really admire the amount of work that goes into each article. As someone who spent way too much time surfing the SH forums in search of the best mastering for every classic album, this is right up my alley. I also appreciate the mixture of objective and subjective analysis. Looking forward to more!

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    2 hours ago, LucasZ said:

    👋 Hi, long-time reader, first time poster. Just wanted to say that I've greatly enjoyed the entire series of TBVO and I really admire the amount of work that goes into each article. As someone who spent way too much time surfing the SH forums in search of the best mastering for every classic album, this is right up my alley. I also appreciate the mixture of objective and subjective analysis. Looking forward to more!


    Thanks so much, Lucas. A big part of the motivation for TBVO was reading the SHF forums. It whet my appetite for finding the best mastering, but with so few (if any) members having every version, let alone comparing them level-matched, I alway ended up feeling like I needed to just track them all down myself!

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    1 hour ago, JoshM said:


    Thanks so much, Lucas. A big part of the motivation for TBVO was reading the SHF forums. It whet my appetite for finding the best mastering, but with so few (if any) members having every version, let alone comparing them level-matched, I alway ended up feeling like I needed to just track them all down myself!

    i'm a great admirer of your work. I wondered for a while if there was room for a kind of "back of the enveloppe" TBVO thread where we could share tips and maybe Musicscope captures but in the end I think it would end up subjective and unstructured and there's SHF for that. Your work is unique and, yes, the best we can do is encourage you to produce more 

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I have a new post up about how to support artists in the age of streaming:

     

     

    This is the first of a two-post article. The second will get into the ethical and practical factors that go into sourcing versions of albums for my TBVOs.

     

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now



×
×
  • Create New...