Jump to content
  • Sajid Amit
    Sajid Amit

    Part 1: Headphone Impressions from A recent “Audiophile Trip” to India

     

     

    For those of who haven’t seen my YouTube videos on the Amplify YouTube Channel or my posts on HeadFi or its Facebook group, my name is Sajid Amit and this is my first piece for Audiophile Style. I have followed Chris’s work closely, so was rather delighted at this opportunity to contribute to this exciting publication.

     

    I recently traveled to India where I was a part of 4 or 5 audiophile meets. The largest one was organized by Sennheiser in Gurgaon, New Delhi Commercial Region, India. And what a wonderful meet it was. Other than various Sennheiser headphones, and other gears audiophiles had brought with them, I got to hear the HE-1!

     

    Sajid 01.jpg

     

     

     

    I also spent some time listening to headphones at Headphone Zone in Mumbai. HPZ is India’s largest audiophile store and the flagship headphones they have on display, is quite diverse and impressive.

     

    For reference, I personally own the Hifiman Susvara, Abyss AB-1266 Phi TC, Raal SR1a, Stax 009S, and the Focal Stellia, and have the Audeze LCD5 incoming.

     

    What follows are my impressions on all the headphones I listened to on this trip, in no particular order, some for the first time, and others, for the second or third. I also hope to soon update my ranking here.

     

     

    So here goes.

     

    Sennheiser IE 900:

     

    The IE900s are impressive monitors. In fact, they may have been the best IEMs I heard on this trip.  What stands out about these monitors is their fast, snappy, detailed, and hard-hitting bass as well as an infinite treble extension, without ever being bright or sibilant. Also surprising is how good the midrange is on this IEM, despite being a tad recessed. Despite the midrange recession, the presentation still sounds natural. There is plenty of detail, staging is wide, certainly aided by the V-shaped FR, whilst dynamics are solid, and timbre is quite good. The only shortcoming worth pointing out is the cable is total janky junk.

     

     

    Sennheiser IE900.jpg

     

     

     

     

     

    HIFMAN HE1000 V2:

     

    I didn’t like the HE1000 V2 a lot. I know many love the HEKV2, but to my ears, they were bright and the dynamics reminded me of the Susvara – too polite for my ears. Politeness can be a desirable trait if the entire presentation is like the Susvara’s, i.e., smooth, flowing, organic, etc., which can lend itself well to genres like classical, acoustic, jazz, etc.

     

    However, I wasn’t sure what genres I would listen to the V2 with. I thought the staging wasn’t noticeably wide or deep, imaging was fine, and detail retrieval was probably very good. It sounded like a brighter, slightly bassier, and noticeably less technically-adept Susvara with those oval caps I never liked.

     

     

    HE1000.jpg

     

     

     

     

     

    FOCAL Stellia:

     

    The Focal Stellia is my current favorite closed-back. I was a fan of the HIFIMAN HE-R10P when I first heard it, probably because it was a reasonable complement to my Susvara, which was my only TOTL headphone at that time. But once I bought the Abyss TC, and got used to it, it made the HE-R10P redundant.

     

    Comparing the Stellia to the R10P, the Stellia has a far better tonality. The bass is elevated and is great fun, the midrange sounds natural, and the treble is forward without ever being in-your-face or peaky.

     

    Dynamics are outstanding, as is Focal’s wont. Staging is impressive for a closedback with great layering and imaging. In fact, with regard to stage, there is not a whole lot to choose between the Utopia and the Stellia, for me.

     

    It is a near-flawless headphone, with outstanding aesthetics. The unequivocal weakness is its stock cable which is janky, and an area of contention could be its timbre, which can sound metallic in the treble. I quite like it because percussion instruments sound great as a result of the hard, slightly metallic presentation.

     

     

    Focal Stellia.jpg

     

     

     

     

     

    Sennheiser HD820:

     

    I was not a fan of this headphone, so I won’t spend too much dwelling on its impressions. It had a nice midrange when you first listen to it and a decent sense of staging and imaging. But there is serious wonkiness in the tonality. It is a muddy-sounding headphone with clear bass bleed and a strange implementation of the presence region, causing it to sound boxy, unclear and congested. It is a classic reminder of how hard it is to build flagship level closed-backs. Even more reason to appreciate the Stellia.

     

     

    Sennheiser.jpg

     

     

     

     

     

    The HEDDphone:

     

    HEDD Audio’s headphone was a mixed bag. Yes, it is technically as proficient as people say it is, while being extremely hard to drive, and ridiculously uncomfortable for long-listening. I didn’t like the implementation of the cups or the yoke or the overall weight. Easily the worst headphone I have tried in terms of comfort.

     

    However, it is a performance-oriented headphone with an incredible treble that is detailed, silky, and enjoyable, and overall great detail retrieval and good dynamics across the frequency range.

     

    Other than its comfort, the HEDDphone has no faults. The midrange can be thin sounding but I know people who like the midrange. Overall, if you can deal with the comfort, it is probably a bargain at MSRP and even more so at used prices, as the HEDDPhone tends to not hold value in the secondary market.

     

     

     

    Hedd.jpg

     

     

     

     

     

    Stax SR009S:

     

    I have a Stax SR009S incoming. I ordered a Stax SR009S and a KGSHHV Carbon because I wanted sufficient time with TOTL e-stats. And I am still hoping that off the Carbon, the 009S will please more than it did off the Stax amp and the Cayin DAC. However, on this setup, the 009S was a rather mixed experience. It sounded a lot like the Susvara in some ways but could be peaky on certain tracks.

     

    This was still a “natural” sounding e-stat compared to many others. The midrange is reminiscent of the Susvara’s midrange. And although Stax’s own amp could not push its bass to its potential limits, I am aware that the bass can sound better off the KGSSHV Carbon. It is a more detailed headphone than the Susvara in my opinion, and technically at the same level as an Abyss AB-1266 Phi TC. Imaging is worldclass and staging is very deep, perhaps the deepest I have heard, without being spectacularly wide.

     

     

    Stax.jpg

     

     

     

     

     

    Audeze LCD-2 (Classics) and LCD-3:

     

    I am not a fan of the older LCD headphones. I do have an LCD-5 incoming and I am extremely curious to try the CRBN, and this is inspired by the 2021 tunings of the Audeze LCD-X and the LCD-XC 2021.

     

    Yes, as is well-known, the LCD-2 and 3 sound warm, creamy, inviting, with a nice midrange and decent bass, but I always find them boring and lackluster after a while. Their technical performance is fine for their respective price points, but I enjoy the macrodynamic of a Focal Clear more than what these headphones offer, and the resolution, timbre and staging of the HD800 or an HD800s. The lack of energy in upper midrange, to me, is a serious drawback.

     

     

    Audeze LCD-2C.jpg

     

     

     

     

     

    Audeze LCD-XC 2021:

     

    Although I prefer the Celeste over the LCDXC 2021, it is still a solid closedback headphone for the price.

     

    The XC 2021 retains the warmth and body of the LCD lineup with a more present upper midrange. The detail retrieval, staging, and imaging are all great for the price. The reason I prefer the Celeste is that it has better macrodynamics, and overall, a superior tonality.

     

    The Stellia is a clearly better headphone than the XC, but you would expect that given price differences. Switching between the XC and the Stellia, the first thing you notice is the sense of space and layering in the Stellia – very open-back-like.

     

     

    Focal Audeze.jpg

     

     

     

     

     

    That’s it for Part 1 of my two-part series on headphone, IEM, and amp/DAC impressions. Part 2 is forthcoming!

     

     

     

    Sajid.jpgSajid Amit is an academic, researcher and practitioner in international development by day, and audiophile night and day. His YouTube channel is called the Amplify Audiophile Show. 

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     




    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    20 hours ago, The Computer Audiophile said:

    Welcome to AS @Sajid Amit! I love these types of articles. If you would've included a little tea tasting, it would've made my day. I'm a tea snob :~)

     

    Anyway, nice to read about the Sennheiser IE900. I'm thinking about getting a pair to replace some custom IEMs. 

    Thank you, Sir. Yes, the IE900 was quite enjoyable. It reminded me how I am a closet Sennheiser fan-boy, lol. The bass was rather memorable. 

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    19 hours ago, davide256 said:

    Nice to read your review, very helpful. It does seem to be real, that everyone's hearing is different whether natively or due to "ear training"

    over time. I found this podcast informative, actual documentation that everyone's brain processes sound differently.

     

    From silence to cacophony, here's how your brain makes sense of the world

     

    Have always enjoyed the Audeze sound because the instruments sound more harmonically correct (to me).

    But the sheer weight of their better headphones  is reason to pause and consider purchasing their IEM's instead

     

    True. We do hear so differently. Countless studies on this. I have lots of friends who love the Audeze sound. I am waiting on my LCD5. Hope to drop a review of that as well. 

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Thank you, Sajid, for the international perspective! Out of curiosity, do you have any well recorded and well performed Indian artists you'd recommend? I'm curious about anything from complex classical music to modern mash-ups or modern "alternative" (for the Indian audience). I suppose I get some of this from British artists but I just thought I'd ask because perhaps you have particular tracks or artists or performances you like for evaluating cans/speakers?

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    9 minutes ago, feelingears said:

    Thank you, Sajid, for the international perspective! Out of curiosity, do you have any well recorded and well performed Indian artists you'd recommend? I'm curious about anything from complex classical music to modern mash-ups or modern "alternative" (for the Indian audience). I suppose I get some of this from British artists but I just thought I'd ask because perhaps you have particular tracks or artists or performances you like for evaluating cans/speakers?


    I bet @Nikhil has some recommendations. 

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    On 11/5/2021 at 6:24 AM, Sajid Amit said:

    True. We do hear so differently. Countless studies on this. I have lots of friends who love the Audeze sound. I am waiting on my LCD5. Hope to drop a review of that as well. 

    Tried them at CAF, quite a bit lighter ~400 gms. Source was just an IPad so couldn’t really assess if they were worth the cost

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    2 hours ago, The Computer Audiophile said:


    I bet @Nikhil has some recommendations. 

     

    It's late here but here are some ...

     

    Pentagram

    Blackstratblues

    Soulmate

    Parikrama

     

    Will add more as they come to mind. 

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    10 hours ago, feelingears said:

    Thank you, Sajid, for the international perspective! Out of curiosity, do you have any well recorded and well performed Indian artists you'd recommend? I'm curious about anything from complex classical music to modern mash-ups or modern "alternative" (for the Indian audience). I suppose I get some of this from British artists but I just thought I'd ask because perhaps you have particular tracks or artists or performances you like for evaluating cans/speakers?

    Hey man, afraid don't listen to too many Indian artists. I ought to. 

     

    When I was in graduate school at Columbia, I went to a concert of this Indian band called Indian Ocean. Not sure if they still exist. 

     

    My wife likes Indian music more than I, lol.

     

    I grew up mostly in the US, so my test tracks are pretty standard, from rock and pop to indie, jazz, metal, etc. I was a metal head growing up but now listen to everything really, given how different headphones play well with different genres. 

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    5 hours ago, Rae said:

    I've been enjoying my IE 900 since June, and it's been like mind blowing experience. Coming from full size HD 800, HD 820, and IEMs like IE 800 and IE 800 S, and now IE 900. IE 900 are undoubtedly the best IEM I have ever owned. I am using them with HDV 820 with balanced 4.4mm. So pure and natural sound. But Sennheiser really need to learn how to make a good case for IEMs like 800 or 900. Their cases on all premium IEMs are horrible. Case for IE 800/800S not that bad, but IE900 looks so cheap and worst. Best IEM in the world came with the worst case, imo.  Anyways, I just lay them on my desk straight without bending cables at all as I use them everyday. 

    Indeed. And I am not the biggest fan of their cable. But yeah, the IE900 is a wonderful performer. In general, I notice that my favorite headphones and earphones don't necessarily adhere to the Harman tuning, which is not a fault of the tuning, but technical performance becomes so important for long-term enjoyment. The IE900 punches above its weight class when it comes to technical performance, and punches rather hard. I also like it's V-shaped tuning a lot. A very well-executed V, if you ask me. 

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    8 hours ago, Nikhil said:

     

    It's late here but here are some ...

     

    Pentagram

    Blackstratblues

    Soulmate

    Parikrama

     

    Will add more as they come to mind. 

    Checking them out!

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    9 hours ago, austinpop said:

    Great review, @Sajid Amit. Welcome to Audiophile Style, and hope to see more!

    Thank you. :)

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    16 hours ago, Nikhil said:

     

    It's late here but here are some ...

     

    Pentagram

    Blackstratblues

    Soulmate

    Parikrama

     

    Will add more as they come to mind. 

     

    Elephant Stone

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    On 11/6/2021 at 9:24 PM, Sajid Amit said:

    My wife likes Indian music more than I, lol.

     

    I grew up mostly in the US, so my test tracks are pretty standard, from rock and pop to indie, jazz, metal, etc. I was a metal head growing up but now listen to everything really, given how different headphones play well with different genres. 

     

    I hope it wasn't too presumptuous to think that if you'd travel to India and do a headphone meet up, that you might have some favorites from that "world" to share!

     

    As for metal, well, let's not scare everyone here! lol

    Odd thing is that well-recorded or produced metal is, like all other genres, just that much better on a good system (or at least a tuned system). Bass lines, kick drums, the whole works...

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    10 hours ago, honeymustardsteve said:

    that looks like a kpmg profile photo :)

    True! Lol. 

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    9 hours ago, feelingears said:

     

    I hope it wasn't too presumptuous to think that if you'd travel to India and do a headphone meet up, that you might have some favorites from that "world" to share!

     

    As for metal, well, let's not scare everyone here! lol

    Odd thing is that well-recorded or produced metal is, like all other genres, just that much better on a good system (or at least a tuned system). Bass lines, kick drums, the whole works...

    Nope, not presumptuous at all. I should know more about music in India. I am a big fan of Indian food and a bit of an Indian history enthusiast as well. 

     

    Yes, I agree about well-recorded metal. I have a TC and I really enjoy metal off it. In fact, I hope to do a review of the TC vs the Susvara soon for AS. 

    Share this comment


    Link to comment
    Share on other sites



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now



×
×
  • Create New...